Roof Warranties Explained: Manufacturer vs. Workmanship

In short
A new roof usually carries two warranties. The manufacturer’s warranty covers defects in the shingles and accessories; the contractor’s workmanship warranty covers installation mistakes. Neither covers hail or wind damage beyond the stated limits, which is an insurance matter. Warranties are voided most often by improper installation, missing registration, unapproved alterations and neglect, so get every term in writing before you sign.
Key takeaways
- A manufacturer’s warranty covers product defects; a workmanship warranty covers installation errors, and most roof failures in the first years are installation problems.
- Owens Corning’s standard shingle warranty is non-prorated for the first 10 years and covers materials only after that, without workmanship coverage.
- Enhanced system warranties from Owens Corning and Malarkey require a contractor in the manufacturer’s program and qualifying accessories.
- Hail damage is a storm loss handled through your homeowners insurance, not a warranty claim.
- Ask for the workmanship warranty, its length, what it excludes and how to make a claim, in writing, before you sign.
You are comparing two roofing bids, and both say “lifetime warranty.” One adds “10-year workmanship.” The other does not mention workmanship at all. They sound the same. They are not, and the difference matters more in North Texas than in most places, because our roofs take hail, high wind and long summers of heat that expose every shortcut.
This guide explains what each kind of roof warranty covers, what it does not, what quietly voids it, and the questions to ask before you sign. It is written for homeowners in Plano, Collin County and the rest of Dallas–Fort Worth, but the warranty basics apply anywhere.
What are the two kinds of roof warranty?
Almost every new roof comes with two separate promises from two separate companies.
The manufacturer’s warranty comes from the company that made the shingles and accessories. It covers defects in the product: shingles that crack, lose granules or fail early because of how they were made. It does not cover how they were nailed, flashed or ventilated.
The workmanship warranty comes from the roofing contractor. It covers mistakes in installation: a missed nail line, a badly flashed chimney, a pipe boot set wrong, poor valley work. This is the one that matters most in the first years, because a roof that leaks in year two almost always leaks because of a detail, not a defective shingle.
| Manufacturer warranty | Workmanship warranty | |
|---|---|---|
| Who backs it | The shingle maker | The roofing contractor |
| What it covers | Defects in shingles and accessories | Installation errors: nailing, flashing, ventilation, details |
| Typical structure | Long term, often “limited lifetime,” with a shorter full-value period | Set by the contractor; length varies widely |
| Labor and tear-off | Often only in an early non-prorated period or an upgraded system warranty | Usually included, since it is the contractor’s own labor |
| Hail and wind | Wind blow-off up to stated limits; hail is not a defect | Not covered; storm damage goes to insurance |
| Who files the claim | You, with the manufacturer | You, with the contractor |
Some manufacturers also offer system warranties that add workmanship coverage backed by the manufacturer. Those only exist when a contractor in the manufacturer’s program installs a full system of the maker’s parts, which we cover below.
What does a manufacturer’s shingle warranty actually cover?
We install Malarkey and Owens Corning shingles, so these two are worth looking at closely. Always read the warranty in effect on the day your roof goes on, because terms change.
According to Owens Corning’s published warranty page, its standard product warranty is a limited lifetime warranty on a single-family detached home for as long as the original owner keeps the house. For the first 10 years (Owens Corning calls this the TRU PROtection period), it is non-prorated, but excluding tear-off and disposal. After that it covers materials only. The standard warranty has no workmanship coverage, and any installer can qualify if the installation instructions and local codes are followed.
Malarkey’s warranty page describes a standard limited lifetime shingle and accessory warranty against manufacturing defects that applies no matter which contractor installs the roof. Its enhanced wind coverage depends on nailing: four nails per architectural shingle, five per designer shingle, or more where code requires.
Two words do most of the work in any shingle warranty:
- Prorated means the payout shrinks as the roof ages. A claim in year 18 might pay a fraction of the material cost and none of the labor.
- Non-prorated means full value for a set period, though “full value” may still exclude tear-off, disposal or labor. Read that line.
What about wind and algae coverage?
Owens Corning lists blow-off coverage for the first 15 years, measured after the shingles thermally seal, with higher wind ratings (up to 160 mph) only when its component requirements are met and starter shingles are installed at the eaves and rakes. Its algae resistance coverage runs 25 years with qualifying ridge products and drops to 10 years without them.
The point for a DFW homeowner: the wind number on the brochure depends on the accessories and nailing your roofer actually uses. Ask which components are going on your roof and whether they meet the maker’s requirements for the higher rating. Our guide to Malarkey vs. Owens Corning shingles compares the product lines in more detail.
What do enhanced or system warranties add?
Both manufacturers sell upgraded warranties, and this is where most of the confusion comes from.
Owens Corning’s page lays out three tiers above standard. System Protection adds a 50-year non-prorated period that includes tear-off and disposal, still without workmanship, and requires at least three Owens Corning components. Preferred Protection adds 10 years of workmanship coverage and needs at least four components including underlayment. Platinum Protection adds limited lifetime workmanship coverage, reduced after 25 years. All three require a contractor in Owens Corning’s Preferred or Platinum program, and the top tier requires a Platinum contractor.
Malarkey’s page describes Certified Pro and Certified Premium warranties. Both require a Malarkey-certified installer and a complete system with a minimum number of Malarkey accessories. Certified Premium includes a 25-year workmanship warranty on the shingle and accessory installation. The contractor registers these through Malarkey’s portal.
The practical question is simple: which warranty will actually be registered on your roof, and is the contractor eligible to register it? Ask to see it named on the estimate and the registration confirmation after the job. A brochure for a top-tier warranty means nothing if the roof was installed under the standard one.
What does a workmanship warranty cover, and why does it matter most?
The workmanship warranty is the contractor’s promise about their own labor. There is no industry standard for its length or wording, which is exactly why you need it in writing.
A strong workmanship warranty states:
- How many years it lasts, starting from what date
- What it covers: leaks from installation, flashing, nailing, ventilation and accessory work
- What it excludes, stated plainly
- Whether it covers interior damage caused by a covered leak
- How to make a claim and how quickly the contractor responds
- Whether it transfers to a buyer if you sell
Verde’s own warranty terms are not something this article can state for you. Ask us for the workmanship warranty in writing with your estimate, and ask every other contractor you are considering for the same. A company that will not put it on paper is telling you something. Our list of questions to ask a roofer before you sign includes the exact warranty questions.
When I look at a roof that failed early, the shingles are rarely the problem. It is usually the step flashing behind a wall, a pipe boot or an exposed nail head. That is workmanship.
What voids a roof warranty?
Warranties are written with exclusions, and most voided claims trace back to a handful of them. Owens Corning conditions its standard coverage on following the installation instructions and local codes, and NRCA notes that most roof warranties require proper maintenance.
Common ways homeowners and contractors void coverage:
- Improper installation. Wrong nail count or placement, missing starter strip, or skipped components the warranty requires.
- Poor attic ventilation. Shingle makers specify ventilation, and North Texas attics get extremely hot. An under-vented attic can cook shingles from below. See our guide to underlayment and ventilation.
- Layering over an old roof when the manufacturer or code does not allow it.
- Alterations by others. A satellite installer, solar crew or HVAC tech cutting into the roof without proper flashing.
- Neglect. Clogged gutters and valleys, tree limbs rubbing the surface, or ignoring damage until it spreads.
- Missing registration or transfer deadlines. Some upgraded warranties only exist once registered.
- Pressure washing or walking the roof carelessly, which strips granules.
Keep a folder with your contract, the registration confirmation, the invoice, photos of the finished roof and any repair records. If you ever file a claim, that folder is your case.
Does a roof warranty cover hail or storm damage?
No, not in the way most people hope. A hailstone bruising a shingle is not a manufacturing defect, and it is not an installation mistake. It is a storm loss, and in Texas that goes through your homeowners insurance policy.
That means your deductible applies. Texas Insurance Code chapter 707 requires the policyholder to pay the deductible, and the Texas Department of Insurance states that it is illegal for a contractor to offer to waive, rebate or absorb it. Any contractor who suggests the warranty or a “deal” will cover your deductible is offering something the law forbids. Our roof deductible guide explains the rule.
If hail hits your roof, get it inspected and documented, then decide with your insurer whether to file. We walk through that on our storm and hail damage page and in what to do after a hailstorm.
Can a roof warranty transfer when you sell the house?
This comes up often in DFW, where homes change hands fast. A transferable warranty can be a selling point, but only if the transfer is done on time.
- Owens Corning allows transfer to a second owner within 60 days of the real estate transfer, online or by phone, and some warranties charge a fee.
- Malarkey lists a 30-day transfer window for its standard warranty, or 60 days for roofs installed after July 2016, and a one-time transfer within 60 days for Certified Pro and Premium warranties.
- Workmanship warranties transfer only if the contractor’s written terms say so.
If you are buying, ask the seller for the original contract and warranty registration. If you are selling, read our guide to roof inspections when selling a house.
Warranty checklist before you sign
Use this list with every bid on a roof replacement:
- Which manufacturer warranty will be registered, by name and tier?
- Is the contractor eligible to register that tier?
- Which accessories (starter, underlayment, hip and ridge, ventilation) are included, and do they meet the warranty’s requirements?
- What is the workmanship warranty length, start date and exclusions?
- Does it cover interior damage from a covered leak?
- How do you file a claim, and how fast does the contractor respond?
- Is either warranty transferable, and what is the deadline?
- Will you receive the registration confirmation in writing?
Line these answers up next to the price on how to read a roofing estimate. The cheapest bid with no written workmanship warranty is rarely the cheapest roof.
Want the warranty terms explained on your own roof?
Chris inspects the roof with you, documents what he finds with photos, and gives you a written estimate after a free inspection, with the products and warranty terms spelled out so you can compare. Call or text (214) 687-1951, 24/7, or book a free roof inspection.
Questions people ask next
Does a roof warranty cover hail damage in Texas?
Generally no. Shingle warranties cover manufacturing defects, and some cover wind blow-off up to a stated speed for a set period. Hail that bruises or cracks shingles is a storm loss, so it goes through your homeowners insurance policy and your deductible, not through the manufacturer or the roofer’s workmanship warranty.
Is a lifetime roof warranty really for life?
Lifetime usually means as long as you, the original owner, own the home, and the full-value part is much shorter. Owens Corning’s standard warranty, for example, is non-prorated for 10 years and covers materials only after that. Read the proration table to see what a claim in year 20 would actually pay.
Can I transfer my roof warranty when I sell my house?
Often yes, but on a deadline. Owens Corning allows transfer to a second owner within 60 days of the real estate transfer, sometimes with a fee. Malarkey’s standard warranty transfer is due within 30 or 60 days of title transfer depending on install date. Workmanship warranty transfer depends entirely on the contractor’s written terms.
Will a satellite dish or solar panels void my roof warranty?
They can if the installer cuts into the roof without proper flashing or damages shingles, because warranties exclude damage from alterations and improper installation by others. Before any rooftop install, ask your roofer and the manufacturer what is allowed, and keep the installer’s paperwork with your roof records.
What should I do if my new roof leaks?
Call the roofer who installed it first, in writing as well as by phone, and photograph the leak and the ceiling. A leak in the first years is almost always an installation detail covered by workmanship terms. Do not let another company open the roof before the original installer looks, since that can complicate coverage.
Sources
Keep reading
Related guides
Hiring a roofer25 Questions to Ask a Roofer Before You SignBefore hiring a roofer, ask where the company is based, how it is insured, who pulls the permit, who does the work, exactly which materials and…Read the guide
Roofing materialsMalarkey vs. Owens Corning Shingles: How to Compare the Two BrandsBoth are reputable manufacturers with Class 4 impact-rated shingles, so the better choice depends on the specific product line, color, warranty path and installer, not the…Read the guide
Cost & financingHow to Read a Roofing Estimate Line by LineA complete roofing estimate lists the company’s full contact details, the measured squares and waste factor, how many layers come off, the exact shingle line, underlayment…Read the guide 

