Call or text 24/7 · 24-hour emergency service Plano, TX 5.0 · 54 Google reviews
Verde Roofing & Construction
Hiring a roofer

25 Questions to Ask a Roofer Before You Sign

Verde Roofing crew members walking a shingle roof during an inspection

In short

Before hiring a roofer, ask where the company is based, how it is insured, who pulls the permit, who does the work, exactly which materials and accessories are included, how rotted decking is priced, what the written workmanship warranty covers, which manufacturer warranty will be registered, and how payments are scheduled. On an insurance job, also ask how they document damage, and walk away from any offer to waive your deductible.

Key takeaways

  • Texas has no state roofing license, so your questions do the screening that a license board does in other states.
  • Ask for a certificate of insurance and verify it, because most private Texas employers are not required to carry workers’ compensation.
  • Get the exact shingle line, accessories, decking price and ventilation plan in writing, not just a total.
  • On insurance jobs of $1,000 or more, Texas law requires a deductible notice in the contract, and no contractor may waive your deductible or act as your public adjuster.
  • Separate the roofer’s workmanship warranty from the manufacturer’s warranty and get both in writing.

You have a roofer at the kitchen table, an estimate in your hand and a lot riding on the decision. A new roof is one of the largest checks most homeowners write, and in North Texas there is no state license board doing the screening for you.

These 25 questions do that screening. For each one, here is why it matters and what a good answer sounds like. Print the list, take notes during each meeting, and compare answers as carefully as you compare prices.

Questions about the company

  1. Where is your office, and how long have you worked in this area? You want a physical DFW address you could drive to, not just a cell number. A good answer names a street address and neighborhoods where they work regularly. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) recommends hiring local firms.
  1. Can I see a certificate of insurance for general liability? A good roofer hands it over or has its agent email it. Call the agency listed to confirm the policy is current.
  1. Does your crew have workers’ compensation coverage? TDI says most private Texas employers are not required to carry it. A clear answer either way is what matters; if a worker without coverage is hurt on your property, you want to know where you stand. TDI links to a public lookup you can use to verify a policy.
  1. Do you hold any credentials I can verify myself? Texas does not license roofers. Voluntary credentials include the RCAT license, trade association membership and manufacturer contractor programs. RCAT notes its license and its membership are separate, and that a credential does not guarantee the work, so ask which one they hold and look it up. Our guide on Texas roofing licenses explains each.
  1. Who will actually be on my roof? Ask whether the crew is in-house or subcontracted, and who supervises on site. A good answer names a project manager or foreman and says how often they will be there.
  1. Can I talk to two or three customers whose roofs you did a few years ago? Older references show how the work held up through hail seasons and Texas heat.

Questions about permits and the job itself

  1. Who pulls the permit, and will I get the permit number? Most DFW cities require a permit for a full reroof. The answer should be “we do,” with the number provided before work starts.
  1. Will you tear off down to the deck? A full tear-off lets the roofer inspect and repair the decking. Ask how many existing layers there are.
  1. What happens if you find rotted or damaged decking? A good estimate includes a per-sheet price for replacement and a promise of photos before and after.
  1. Exactly which shingle line and color are included? “Architectural shingles” is not specific enough. You want the brand, line and color on paper.
  1. Which underlayment, ice and water barrier and drip edge will you use, and where? These hidden layers are where incomplete bids cut corners. Our guide to underlayment, ventilation and decking explains what each one does.
  1. Will flashing be replaced or reused? Step flashing, chimney flashing and pipe boots are common leak points. Ask what will be new.
  1. How did you calculate my attic ventilation? A good answer mentions measuring the attic and balancing intake and exhaust, not just “we’ll add a ridge vent.”
  1. How will you protect my house, landscaping and driveway? Look for tarps over plants, plywood or protection near the driveway, and a plan for the attic if debris falls through.
  1. How long will the job take, and what happens if it rains? Ask how they dry-in a roof mid-job and how they communicate weather delays. Our guide on what to expect on roof replacement day walks through a typical day.
  1. How do you clean up? You want magnetic nail sweeps of the yard and driveway and full debris removal included in the price.

Questions about insurance claims

  1. How will you document the damage? A good roofer walks the roof, photographs every slope and the damaged components, and gives you copies. That is the approach Chris takes: inspect with the owner, document with photos, explain repair versus replacement before a claim is filed.
  1. Will you meet my adjuster on site? Many good roofers will, to show the damage they documented. Our guide to the adjuster’s roof inspection explains what happens at that meeting.
  1. What will you do about my deductible? The only right answer is “nothing: you pay it.” TDI says it is against the law for a contractor to offer to waive your deductible or work it into a bid. Texas Business & Commerce Code §27.02 makes advertising or providing work that waives, absorbs or rebates a deductible a Class B misdemeanor.
  1. Will you negotiate my claim? The right answer is no. Texas Insurance Code §4102.163 bars a contractor from acting as a public adjuster on a property where it provides contracting services, or advertising to adjust claims. A good roofer explains that it will document, meet the adjuster and write a repair estimate, while you own the claim. If the insurer’s estimate misses items, the roofer can document them for a supplement request that you submit.

Questions about the contract and payment

  1. What is the payment schedule? TDI warns against large or full payments up front. Payments tied to milestones, such as material delivery and completion, protect both sides. Our guide on paying for a new roof covers the options.
  1. Does the contract include the deductible notice? On jobs of $1,000 or more expected to be paid from insurance, §27.02 requires a notice in at least 12-point bold type stating that Texas law requires the insured to pay any deductible. Its absence is a warning sign.
  1. How are changes and extra work approved? A good contract says added work, such as extra decking, is priced in advance and approved in writing.

Questions about warranties

  1. What does your workmanship warranty cover, and for how long, in writing? This is the roofer’s own promise about installation. Get the terms on paper. Our guide to roof warranties explains what to look for.
  1. Which manufacturer warranty will be registered, and who registers it? Manufacturers offer a standard defect warranty and stronger coverage that depends on contractor status and accessories. Malarkey, for example, ties its Certified Pro and Premium warranties to certified contractors installing a set number of its accessories, and only the Premium level includes workmanship coverage. Ask for the warranty name and the registration certificate after the job.

What do good and bad answers sound like?

Use this table during each meeting:

TopicGood answerWarning sign
LocationStreet address in DFWOnly a cell number or out-of-state plates
InsuranceCertificate emailed from the agent“We’re covered, don’t worry”
Permit“We pull it; here is the number”“You don’t need one”
MaterialsExact line, color and accessories listed“Architectural shingles, top quality”
DeckingPer-sheet price, photos“We’ll see when we get there”
Deductible“You pay it; it’s the law”“We can take care of that”
Claim“We document and meet the adjuster”“We’ll handle everything with your insurance”
PaymentMilestone scheduleLarge deposit today
WarrantyWritten workmanship terms plus manufacturer warranty nameVerbal promises only

Our guide to roofing contract red flags covers the paperwork side in more detail.

What should I have ready before the roofer arrives?

The meeting goes better, and the answers are easier to compare, when every roofer works from the same information. Before the first appointment, gather:

  • Your insurance policy’s declarations page, so you know your deductible and whether the roof is covered at replacement cost or actual cash value.
  • The claim number and adjuster’s name, if you have already filed.
  • The insurer’s estimate, if you have one, so each roofer can point out anything it misses.
  • Your own photos of damage, leaks or ceiling stains, with dates.
  • HOA rules on approved shingle colors and any submittal process.
  • Any past roof paperwork: the last installation invoice, warranty certificate or repair receipts.
  • A notepad with this list, so you can write each roofer’s answers in the same place.

Give every roofer the same documents and ask each to itemize. Then the differences you see are real differences in scope, not in what each one was told.

Which questions matter most after a hailstorm?

After a storm, the pressure is highest and the field is most crowded, so a few questions carry extra weight. Focus on numbers 1, 2, 7, 17, 19 and 20: where the company is, how it is insured, who pulls the permit, how damage is documented, what happens to your deductible and whether the roofer understands that the claim is yours. TDI warns that out-of-town scam artists often arrive first after a disaster. A roofer who answers those six well has usually earned the rest of the conversation.

How should I use these answers to decide?

After you have met with three roofers, lay the notes side by side. Then:

  1. Cross off anyone who offered to waive the deductible, pressured you to sign or would not show insurance.
  2. Compare the remaining bids line by line using our guide on how to read a roofing estimate.
  3. Call two references for each finalist.
  4. Pick the roofer whose answers were specific, written and consistent, even if it is not the lowest number.

When a homeowner hands me a list like this, I take it as a good sign. People who ask careful questions tend to end up with roofs they are happy with, whoever they hire. For the bigger picture, read our guide on how to choose a roofing contractor in DFW, and if your roof has storm damage, see how our insurance claim help works.

Want to ask us all 25?

Chris is glad to go through every question on this list during a free inspection, on your roof and at your kitchen table. Call or text (214) 687-1951 (24/7) or book a free roof inspection.

Questions people ask next

Should I ask a roofer for references, or are online reviews enough?

Ask for both. Reviews show patterns across many customers; references let you ask specific questions, such as whether the crew showed up when promised and how a problem was fixed. A roof done three or four years ago is the most useful reference, because it shows how the work held up through a few North Texas summers and storms.

What if a roofer will not answer some of these questions?

Treat it as an answer. A contractor who will not show a certificate of insurance, name the shingle line or put the warranty in writing is telling you how the job will go. Good roofers are used to these questions, and most will answer them before you ask.

Is it rude to get three bids?

No. The Texas Department of Insurance recommends getting at least three bids, and professional roofers expect it. Tell each one you are comparing, give them all the same information, and ask them to itemize so you can compare scope rather than just totals.

Can I ask the roofer to meet my insurance adjuster?

Yes. Many homeowners ask their roofer to be there during the adjuster’s inspection to point out the damage they documented. The roofer can show what it found and answer technical questions, but under Texas law it cannot act as your public adjuster. You and your insurer make the decisions.

How much should I pay up front for a new roof?

There is no single legal figure for every job, but the Texas Department of Insurance warns against large or full payments up front, and says out-of-town contractors may not require a down payment before starting work after a disaster. Tie payments to milestones such as material delivery and completion, and never pay in full before the work is done.

Sources

  1. Texas Department of Insurance: How to avoid contracting scams
  2. Texas Department of Insurance: Workers’ compensation coverage verification
  3. Roofing Contractors Association of Texas: Find a licensed Texas roofing company
  4. Texas Business & Commerce Code §27.02: Deductible notice in contracts paid by insurance
  5. Texas Insurance Code §4102.163: Certain contractor business prohibited
  6. Malarkey Roofing Products: Warranties
About the author

Chris Grimes owns Verde Roofing in Plano, Texas, a locally owned residential and commercial roofer serving Dallas–Fort Worth. Verde is an NTRCA Accredited Member, an RCAT member and a Dallas Observer Best of Dallas Best Roofer winner (readers’ choice) in 2021, 2022 and 2023.

CallText