Call or text 24/7 · 24-hour emergency service Plano, TX 5.0 · 54 Google reviews
Verde Roofing & Construction
Insurance claims

ACV vs. RCV: Roof Depreciation and the Second Insurance Check

Verde Roofing crew members walking a shingle roof during an inspection

In short

With replacement cost (RCV) coverage, the insurer usually pays your roof claim in two checks: first the actual cash value, which is replacement cost minus depreciation and your deductible, then the withheld depreciation after the work is done and you send proof. With actual cash value (ACV) coverage, depreciation is not paid back. In Texas, the insurer can require proof you paid your deductible before releasing it.

Key takeaways

  • TDI defines actual cash value as the current cost to replace property minus depreciation.
  • Replacement cost policies usually pay the actual cash value first and the rest after repairs start and you show proof.
  • Texas Insurance Code §707.004 lets the insurer hold the withheld depreciation until you prove you paid your deductible.
  • TDI warns that as roofs age, some insurers switch roof coverage to actual cash value, so check your declarations every year.
  • Your policy sets the deadline to finish repairs and claim the depreciation; missing it can cost you the second check.

The insurer approved your roof claim, and then the check arrived. It is far less than your roofer's estimate, sometimes by thousands of dollars. Before you assume something went wrong, look at the estimate for two lines: depreciation and deductible. They usually explain the gap.

This guide explains actual cash value and replacement cost, why the first check is short, how to get the second one, and the Texas rule that ties the second check to your deductible.

What is the difference between ACV and RCV on a roof?

The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) defines the terms in its home insurance glossary. Actual cash value is "the value of your property, based on the current cost to replace it minus depreciation." Replacement cost pays the amount needed to replace the damaged property without deducting depreciation, up to the policy's limit. Depreciation is the decrease in value over time from use and wear.

Replacement cost (RCV)Actual cash value (ACV)
What it pays in the endThe cost to replace the roof at current prices, up to policy limitsReplacement cost minus depreciation
DepreciationWithheld at first, then paid after repairsSubtracted and not paid back
Number of checksUsually twoUsually one
Your deductibleSubtracted from the paymentSubtracted from the payment
Effect of roof ageAge affects the first check, not the final totalOlder roof, lower payment
Who has itMany standard homeowners policies, especially on newer roofsSome policies, and some older roofs under otherwise replacement cost policies

The difference can be large on an older roof. With ACV coverage on a roof near the end of its life, depreciation can take a big share of the replacement cost, and that money does not come back.

Why was the first insurance check less than the roof costs?

On a replacement cost policy, the first check is usually the actual cash value. TDI's storm FAQ says the first check "will likely be for the actual cash value," and that once you have started repairs and show proof, the company sends the remainder up to replacement cost. TDI's claim guide describes the same two payments: estimated repair costs minus depreciation first, then a second payment after repairs.

Your deductible is also subtracted. So the first check is roughly replacement cost, minus depreciation, minus deductible.

Here is a made-up example to show the math only. It is not a price for any roof:

LineExample amount
Replacement cost on the insurer's estimate$20,000
Minus depreciation withheld−$6,000
Actual cash value$14,000
Minus your deductible−$2,000
First check$12,000
Second check after the work and proof$6,000
Total from insurance$18,000
You pay (your deductible)$2,000

In this example, the roof costs $20,000, insurance pays $18,000 over two checks, and you pay the $2,000 deductible. Your own numbers depend on your estimate, your roof's age and your deductible.

How do insurers calculate roof depreciation?

Insurers estimate how much of the roof's useful life was used up before the storm, based mainly on its age, the material and its condition. A newer roof has little depreciation; an older one has more. Depreciation is usually applied to materials and sometimes to labor, depending on the insurer and policy.

Because depreciation is an estimate of the roof's value just before the storm, it is only as accurate as the facts behind it. Two things to check on your estimate:

  • The roof's age. If the insurer recorded the wrong age, the depreciation will be wrong. A permit, an installation invoice or a closing document can prove it.
  • Condition notes. If the estimate describes the roof as worn or deteriorated and you have photos showing otherwise, send them.

If you disagree, TDI says to tell the company why and send supporting documents.

Can your insurer switch your roof to actual cash value?

Yes, and many homeowners do not notice until they file. TDI's guide to replacing your roof says that as roofs age, some companies switch to actual cash value, and that if a roof is in poor condition, the company might not cover it at all. TDI adds that your company should tell you when it changes your coverage.

The change often appears as an endorsement or a roof payment schedule at renewal. Check your declarations page every year, especially once your roof is past its first decade. When you replace the roof, tell your insurer and ask whether coverage goes back to replacement cost. That question is a customer inquiry under Texas law, not a claim.

If your roof is getting older and your coverage is at risk of changing, our guides on how long a roof lasts in Texas and whether to repair or replace can help you plan.

Should you choose replacement cost coverage when you buy or renew?

If you have a choice, compare the premium difference with what you would lose on a claim. On a North Texas home, where spring hail can damage a roof in a single afternoon, the gap between the two kinds of coverage shows up exactly when you need the money.

Questions worth asking your agent at renewal:

  • Is my roof covered at replacement cost or actual cash value today?
  • Is there a roof payment schedule or roof surfacing endorsement on my policy, and what does it pay at my roof's age?
  • What is my wind and hail deductible, in dollars, not only as a percentage?
  • Does my policy exclude cosmetic hail damage?
  • If I replace my roof, will coverage return to replacement cost, and will my premium change?
  • Is there a discount for impact-resistant roofing?

TDI notes that some companies offer discounts for roofing materials less likely to be damaged by wind, hail or fire. If you are replacing the roof anyway, ask before you choose the shingle. Our guide to the best shingles for Texas hail explains the options, and whether a new roof lowers your insurance covers what to expect on the premium side.

Write down the answers and the date. Coverage terms can change at each renewal, and a written answer from your agent is far easier to rely on than a memory of a phone call.

How do you get the second check for recoverable depreciation?

Follow these steps once the insurer's estimate is final:

  1. Confirm in writing that your policy pays replacement cost and how much depreciation was withheld.
  2. Find your deadline. Your policy sets how long you have to complete repairs and claim the withheld amount. Write it on your calendar.
  3. Sign with your contractor and schedule the work. TDI says the second payment comes once repairs have started and you show proof, so ask your insurer exactly what proof it wants.
  4. Pay your deductible to the contractor and keep proof.
  5. Get the final invoice showing the work is complete and what it cost.
  6. Send the insurer the invoice and deductible proof, plus photos if asked. Note the date and method you sent them.
  7. Follow up if the payment does not arrive. Once the insurer agrees to pay, TDI says it has five business days to send the money.

If your policy is with the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association rather than a standard insurer, TDI notes different rules: for TWIA policies started or renewed after January 1, 2020, you have 545 days to complete repairs for replacement cost.

Why does Texas tie the second check to your deductible?

Because of the law against waived deductibles. Texas Insurance Code §707.004 says an insurer with replacement cost coverage may refuse to pay withheld depreciation until it receives "reasonable proof of payment by the policyholder of any deductible." The statute lists acceptable proof: a canceled check, a money order receipt, a credit card statement, or a copy of an installment or financing contract that requires full payment of the deductible over time.

That rule closes the loophole where a contractor quietly "ate" the deductible and recovered it from the depreciation. In Texas, a contractor may not pay, waive, absorb or rebate your deductible. Our guide to your roof deductible and Texas law explains the rule and the penalties.

When I write an invoice on an insurance job, I show the deductible as its own line, paid by the homeowner. It makes the second check simpler for everyone.

What if the job costs more than the insurer's estimate?

Sometimes the old roof comes off and reveals damaged decking or missing code items the adjuster could not see. The contractor documents what it found with photos and a revised estimate, and the homeowner asks the insurer to review it. That is called a supplement. See what a roof insurance supplement is and code upgrades and matching on a roof claim.

If the insurer will not adjust the amount and you believe it is wrong, our guide on what to do when a roof claim is denied or underpaid explains appraisal, complaints and other options.

Mistakes that cost homeowners the second check

  • Missing the policy deadline to complete repairs
  • Not keeping proof of the deductible payment
  • Signing a check marked as final without asking whether more is owed
  • Accepting a "deal" where the contractor covers the deductible, which is illegal and can stall the claim
  • Not telling the insurer about a lower final cost, which can cause problems later
  • Not checking the roof age on the estimate

For the full claim sequence, read how a roof insurance claim works in Texas.

How Verde helps with the paperwork side

We inspect and document the damage, meet the adjuster on site to show what we found, write a clear estimate and final invoice, and do the work. You own the claim and the decisions on it. See our insurance claims page or try the roof cost calculator to understand what moves a roof's price.

Questions about your estimate or your second check?

If your insurance check does not match your roof estimate and you want someone to walk through it with you, call or text (214) 687-1951, 24/7, or book a free roof inspection. Chris will go over the roof and the numbers with you in plain terms.

Questions people ask next

How do I know if my roof is covered at ACV or replacement cost?

Check your declarations page and endorsements. Look for wording such as actual cash value, replacement cost, or a roof surfacing payment schedule. TDI says some insurers switch older roofs to actual cash value and should tell you when they change coverage. If you are unsure, ask your agent in writing, which Texas law treats as a customer inquiry, not a claim.

Is depreciation negotiable on a roof claim?

Depreciation is the insurer's estimate of how much value the roof lost to age and wear, and it should reflect the roof's condition before the storm. If you think it is too high, for example because the roof is younger than the insurer recorded, tell the insurer in writing and send proof such as the installation invoice or permit.

What documents does the insurer usually want for the second check?

Typically a final invoice from the contractor showing the work is complete, and proof that you paid your deductible. Texas Insurance Code §707.004 lists a canceled check, money order receipt, credit card statement, or a financing contract that requires full payment over time. Some insurers also ask for photos of the finished roof.

What happens if the roof costs less than the insurer's replacement cost estimate?

With replacement cost coverage, insurers generally pay what you actually spent to replace the roof, up to the limits in the policy. If the final cost is lower than the estimate, the second check is usually reduced. If it is higher because of hidden damage, the contractor documents it and you can ask the insurer to review it.

Do I get the depreciation back if I do not replace the roof?

Usually not. Under most replacement cost policies, the withheld depreciation is paid only after the repairs are completed. If you keep the first check and do not do the work, you typically keep only the actual cash value. Read your policy, and if you have a mortgage, check whether your lender requires the money to go toward repairs.

Sources

  1. Texas Department of Insurance: Home insurance glossary
  2. Texas Department of Insurance: Home damaged? FAQ
  3. Texas Department of Insurance: Replacing your roof
  4. Texas Insurance Code §707.004: Reasonable proof of payment
  5. Texas Department of Insurance: Getting your insurance claim paid
  6. Texas Department of Insurance: What if my insurance isn't paying enough?
About the author

Chris Grimes owns Verde Roofing in Plano, Texas, a locally owned residential and commercial roofer serving Dallas–Fort Worth. Verde is an NTRCA Accredited Member, an RCAT member and a Dallas Observer Best of Dallas Best Roofer winner (readers’ choice) in 2021, 2022 and 2023.

Related serviceInsurance Claim Help in Plano & DFW
CallText