Roof Insurance Claim Denied? Your Options in Texas

In short
Start by reading the written denial: Texas insurers must give their reasons in writing. Then send the insurer your roofer's photos and estimate and ask for a re-inspection. If you still disagree, your options in Texas include the policy's appraisal process for disputes over the amount, a licensed public adjuster, a complaint to the Texas Department of Insurance, mediation, or a lawyer.
Key takeaways
- TDI says an insurer that rejects a claim must give the reasons in writing.
- Appraisal settles disagreements over the cost of the damage, not what the policy covers; you pay your appraiser and half the umpire.
- Texas public adjusters must be licensed by TDI and can charge up to 10% of what the insurer pays; you can cancel within 72 hours of signing.
- TDI asks the insurer to respond to a complaint within 15 days but cannot settle factual disputes such as hail versus wear.
- Before suing over a hail or wind claim, Texas Insurance Code §542A.003 generally requires written notice at least 61 days in advance.
The letter from your insurance company says the claim is denied, or the estimate covers a few shingles when your roofer found damage on every slope. It is frustrating, and it can feel final. It usually is not.
Texas gives homeowners several ways forward, from a simple re-inspection to formal appraisal, a complaint to the state or a lawsuit. This guide walks through each one in the order most people use them, with the rules that apply in Texas.
Why do roof insurance claims get denied or underpaid?
Knowing the reason tells you which option fits. The most common reasons are:
| Reason given | What it usually means | What helps |
|---|---|---|
| Wear and tear or age | The insurer believes the damage came from aging, not a storm | Photos of hail hits, soft metal damage and storm-day evidence |
| Damage below the deductible | The covered repair costs less than your wind and hail deductible | A detailed estimate showing the full scope |
| Cosmetic damage exclusion | Dents or marks that do not affect function, often on metal roofs | Evidence of functional damage: open seams, cracked coatings, leaks |
| Not enough hits in test squares | The adjuster found too few hail hits to call for replacement | A re-inspection of all slopes, with photos sorted by slope |
| Late reporting | The insurer says notice came too late under the policy | The storm date, your reporting date and the policy's wording |
| Prior damage or poor installation | The insurer ties the damage to an earlier event or workmanship | Inspection records, permits and installation invoices |
| Underpaid estimate | The claim is approved but items or slopes are missing | A line-by-line comparison with your roofer's estimate |
Some denials are right. Insurance pays for storm damage, not for a roof that is simply old or worn out. If an honest inspection shows age rather than storm damage, the better path may be planning a replacement rather than challenging the decision. See repair or replace your roof.
Step 1: What should you do first after a denial?
Read the letter closely. TDI says that if a company rejects your claim, it must say why in writing. That reason is the target for everything you do next.
Then gather your file:
- The denial letter and the adjuster's estimate
- Your policy, including the declarations page and every endorsement
- Your roofer's inspection report, photos and estimate
- Storm-day photos, hail on the ground, interior damage
- Your log of calls, emails and names
- Receipts for temporary repairs
If the denial cites a specific policy section, find it and read it. If it does not, ask the insurer in writing which provision it relied on.
Step 2: How do you ask the insurer to reconsider?
Start with the company. TDI's guidance is to tell your company why you disagree, because it may have overlooked something, and to send supporting documents such as a contractor's estimate.
Write a short letter or email:
- Your name, address, claim number and the storm date
- What you disagree with, in one or two sentences
- What your roofer found, with photos sorted by slope
- Your roofer's estimate, if the issue is the amount
- A request for a re-inspection, with your availability
If a re-inspection is scheduled, you can have your roofer there to show the damage it documented. Under Texas law, a roofer can show damage and answer construction questions, but may not act as your public adjuster or speak for you on coverage. See the insurance adjuster's roof inspection for how to prepare.
Many underpayments are fixed at this stage, especially when items were missed or a slope was not inspected. Damage found during the job, such as rotten decking, goes through a supplement; see what a roof insurance supplement is.
Step 3: When does appraisal make sense?
Appraisal is a process many homeowners policies include for disputes over the amount of the loss. TDI describes it this way: you and the company each hire an appraiser, and the two appraisers choose a third as the umpire. If the appraisers' estimates differ, the umpire makes the final decision, which is binding on both you and the company.
Key points from TDI:
- Appraisers determine the cost to repair the damage, not what the policy covers
- You pay for your own appraiser and half of the umpire's expenses
- Check your policy for any deadline to demand appraisal
So appraisal fits an underpaid claim, where the insurer agrees the storm caused damage but disagrees on how much. It is a poor fit when the dispute is about coverage itself, such as whether the damage is hail or wear, or whether an exclusion applies. Read your policy's appraisal clause before you invoke it; not every policy has one.
Step 4: Should you hire a public adjuster?
A public adjuster is a professional you hire to represent you on the claim. TDI says public adjusters understand the claims process and are licensed by TDI. Before you sign, know the rules TDI lays out:
| Topic | What TDI says |
|---|---|
| License | Must be licensed by TDI; call 800-252-3439 to check license, complaints and discipline |
| Fee | Up to 10% of the total amount the company pays on your claim |
| Fee base | Can be based on the total settlement, not just the disputed amount |
| Flat fee | You can ask for a dollar amount instead of a percentage |
| If nothing changes | You might still owe the fee if the insurer does not raise its offer |
| Cancellation | You can cancel within 72 hours of signing |
| Contractors | A public adjuster on your claim cannot also be your contractor |
A public adjuster can make sense on a large or complicated claim where the dispute is substantial. On a modest gap, the fee may eat most of what you gain.
This is also why a roofer cannot fill that role. Texas Insurance Code §4102.163 bars a contractor from acting as a public adjuster or advertising to adjust claims on property where it does or may do the work. If a roofer offers to take over the claim for you, see how to spot a storm chaser.
Step 5: How do you file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance?
If you believe the company treated you unfairly or did not follow the law, you can file a complaint with TDI through its online complaint system and upload documents such as photos and letters to and from the company.
How the process works, per TDI:
- TDI contacts the company and asks for a response
- Companies have 15 days to respond and can ask for a 10-day extension
- TDI reviews the response and explains what it means for your complaint
Know the limits, too. TDI can help with complaints about insurers, agents and adjusters it regulates. It cannot make a company pay unless not paying violates the law or the policy, and it will not settle disagreements about facts, such as whether a storm or normal wear caused the damage. TDI also cannot help with complaints about roofers. TDI's Help Line is 800-252-3439, weekdays 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Central.
A complaint works best when the problem is how the claim was handled: missed deadlines, no written reason for a denial, unanswered requests. TDI says your insurer has 15 business days after receiving what it needs to decide, and can extend that by 45 days only if it tells you why it needs more time.
Step 6: When should you talk to a lawyer?
TDI notes that you have the right to sue your insurance company in court, and that you can request alternative dispute resolution, which uses mediation with a neutral third party to settle disputes outside court.
If you are considering a lawsuit over a hail or wind claim, timing rules apply. Texas Insurance Code Chapter 542A covers claims for damage caused wholly or partly by forces of nature, including hail and wind. Under §542A.003, a claimant must give written notice at least 61 days before filing a lawsuit covered by that chapter. Your policy may also set a time limit for suing. A Texas insurance attorney can tell you how those rules apply to your claim; talk to one well before any deadline.
Which option fits your situation?
| Situation | Usually the best next step |
|---|---|
| Items or slopes were missed | Written request for re-inspection with your roofer's photos and estimate |
| Insurer agrees on damage, not on the amount | Appraisal, if your policy has it |
| Large, complex claim and you want representation | A licensed public adjuster |
| Missed deadlines or no written reason | A complaint to TDI |
| Coverage dispute or bad-faith concerns | A Texas insurance attorney |
| Damage is truly age-related | Plan a replacement; see your options for paying |
When I review a denied claim with a homeowner, I start with the photos. If I cannot show clear storm damage, I say so, and we talk about repair or replacement on their own terms instead of chasing a claim that will not hold up.
If paying out of pocket is where you land, see how to pay for a new roof and how long you have to file a roof claim in Texas in case a newer storm is involved.
How Verde can help after a denial
We inspect the roof with you, document the damage with photos, write a detailed estimate, and, if a re-inspection is scheduled, meet the adjuster on site to show the damage we found. We explain what we see and do the work if you hire us. You own the claim and decide which path to take. See our insurance claims page and roof repair page.
Get a second look at your roof
If your claim was denied or underpaid and you want an honest second opinion on the damage, call or text (214) 687-1951, 24/7, or book a free roof inspection. Chris will inspect the roof, photograph what he finds and tell you plainly whether the evidence supports another look from your insurer.
Questions people ask next
Can I refile a roof claim after it was denied?
Usually you ask the insurer to reopen or reconsider the same claim rather than filing a new one for the same storm. Send new evidence in writing: your roofer's photos, a written report and an estimate. If a later, separate storm causes new damage, that is a new claim. Check your policy's deadlines before you wait.
What does it mean when an insurer says my roof damage is wear and tear?
It means the insurer concluded the damage came from age, weathering or poor installation rather than a covered storm. Homeowners policies cover sudden storm damage, not a roof that has simply worn out. If your roofer found hail hits or wind damage, ask for a re-inspection and send the photos showing them.
How much does appraisal cost?
TDI says you pay for the appraiser you hire and half of the umpire's expenses. Appraisers set their own fees, so ask how they charge before you agree. Weigh that cost against the amount in dispute; appraisal makes the most sense when the gap between your estimate and the insurer's is significant.
Can my roofer act as my public adjuster or appraiser?
A roofer cannot act as your public adjuster. Texas Insurance Code §4102.163 bars a contractor from acting as a public adjuster on property where it does or may do the work. Your roofer can still provide its photos, report and estimate as evidence. For appraisal, read your policy's requirements for who may serve as an appraiser.
Will TDI make my insurance company pay my roof claim?
Not directly. TDI can contact the company, ask it to explain its decision and check whether it followed the law and your policy. It cannot make a company pay unless not paying violates the law or the policy, and it will not settle factual disputes such as whether hail or normal wear caused the damage.
Sources
- Texas Department of Insurance: What if my insurance isn't paying enough?
- Texas Department of Insurance: Public adjusters
- Texas Department of Insurance: Homeowners and renters insurance complaint
- Texas Insurance Code §542A.003: Notice required
- Texas Insurance Code §542A.001: Definitions
- Texas Department of Insurance: Insurance claim deadlines
Keep reading
Related guides
Insurance claimsWhat Is a Roof Insurance Supplement and When Is It Needed?A roof insurance supplement is a documented request, made on your existing claim, asking the insurer to add work or materials its first estimate left out…Read the guide
Insurance claimsThe Insurance Adjuster's Roof Inspection: What to Expect and How to PrepareThe adjuster walks the roof, counts hail hits in test areas, checks soft metals, slopes and interior damage, measures the roof and writes an estimate. You…Read the guide
Insurance claimsHow Long Do You Have to File a Roof Claim in Texas?Texas has no single statewide deadline for reporting roof damage on a standard homeowners policy. Your policy sets it: some require notice within a fixed period…Read the guide 

